"This sequel to the author's Yearning for the Impossible provides a readable survey of logicians' efforts to explicate the notions of truth, proof and undecidability, including the quest to find examples of `natural' undecidable statements. Leavened with historical details, it focuses on the role of infinitary considerations in the development of modern mathematics, with particular attention to the undervalued contributions of Emil Post and Gerhard Gentzen."---John W. Dawson, Jr., author of Logical Dilemmas: The Life and Work of Kurt Godel
"Stillwell has provided an accessible, scholarly treatment of all the foundational studies today's well-rounded professional mathematician ought to know, and has managed to do so in just over 200 pages. And that includes all the relevant history. I highly recommend it."---Keith Devlin, Stanford University, author of The Millennium Problems and co-author of The Computer as Crucible: An Introduction to Experimental Mathematics
"Professor Stillwell ... succeeds, in every topic treated, in bringing a fresh eye to questions even mathematicians might think have been mined in the past to boring exhaustion [and] shows there is still a lot of gold to be found, if one only thinks about things in a new way. Stillwell brings new, unorthodox insights to his writing that will stimulate readers (from high schoolers to emeritus professors) to think about old topics in new, nonstale ways."---SIAM Review
"Stillwell weaves historical details into his writing seamlessly, helping to give the reader the true feeling that mathematics is more than just a bunch of people playing games with symbols, but rather a rich and rewarding intellectual endeavor important to the human enterprise."---MAA Reviews
While many popular books have been written on the advances in our understanding of infinity, sparked by the set theory of Georg Cantor in the 1870s and incompleteness theorems of Kurt Godel in the 1930s, such books generally dwell on a single aspect of either set theory or logic. The aim of this book is to explain the whole, in which set theory interacts with logic, and both begin to affect mainstream mathematics (the latter being quite a recent development, not yet given much space in popular accounts).
In Roads to Infinity, award-winning author John Stillwell explores the consequences of accepting infinity, which are rich and surprising. The reader needs very little background beyond high school mathematics, but should have a willingness to grapple with alien ideas. Stillwell's style eases the reader into the technicalities of set theory and logic by tracing a single thread in each chapter, beginning with a natural mathematical question and following a sequence of historic responses to that question. Each response typically leads to new questions, and from them new concepts and theorems emerge. At the end of each chapter a section called "Historical Background" situates the thread in a bigger picture of mathematics and its history.
By following this path, key ideas are presented first, then revisited and reinforced by showing a wider view. Some readers, however, may be impatient to get to the core theorems and will skip the historical background sections, at least at first reading. Others, in search of a big picture from the beginning, may begin by reading the historical background and then come back to fill in details.
Industry Reviews
I highly recommend it for undergraduates in mathematics and other young mathematicians who are looking for historical context or a different angle to their studies. Readers who have experience with theoretical analysis or a foundation in abstract mathematics will find the examples wonderfully illustrative. For these readers, Stillwell's words will flow smoothly, almost like a novel. --Joyance Meechai, Mathematics Teacher, October 2011 In 1963, Edwin E. Moise published Elementary Geometry from an Advanced Standpoint and his book became a classic. ! [this book] deserves the same outcome. ! One of the most enjoyable features is Stillwell's use of techniques of logic and set theory to solve real mathematical problems ! Another enjoyable feature is Stillwell's uniform coverage of unprovability, undecidability and non-computability ! suitable for self-study ! it is excellent background material for computer scientists and mathematicians in other fields. The historical notes alone are worth perusing by anyone who is interested in the development of mathematical ideas. --Phill Schultz, Gazette of the Australian Mathematical Society, March 2011 ! a clear and succinct guide. ! One interesting feature of the book is the careful treatment of two of the less famous contributors in this area--Emil Post and Gerhard Gentzen ! --CMS Notes, Vol. 43, No. 1, February 2011 ! excellent book ! the investment the reader makes--be he an intellectually curious adult or a math grad student with extra time on her hands--pays off with an increased understanding of the fascinating world of mathematical logic. The author's thorough, well-researched historical comments are particularly valuable, as well as the philosophical quotations from the important players in this game. There is a very complete bibliography. What the reader might appreciate most is the ability of the author to share his deep insights into what is important and what it all means in the most profound sense. ! it is clear that the book received excellent proofreading before publication. ! --Mathematical Reviews, Issue 2011f Featuring chapters dedicated to the diagonal argument, ordinals, computability and proof, logic, arithmetic, natural unprovable sentences, and axioms, as well as being enhanced with the inclusion of a lengthy bibliography and a comprehensive index, Roads to Infinity: The Mathematics of Truth and Proof is highly recommended reading for students, scholars, and non-specialist general readers with an interest in the history and contemporary issues of mathematics today. --Able Greenspan, The Midwest Book Review I love reading anything by John Stillwell. If you've ever been tantalized by the puzzles of infinity, set theory, and logic, and want to understand what's really going on, this is the book for you. It's an exceptionally fine piece of mathematical exposition. --Steven Strogatz, Cornell University, author of The Calculus of Friendship