Get Free Shipping on orders over $79
Insolubles : Critical edition with English translation - Walter Segrave

Insolubles

Critical edition with English translation

By: Walter Segrave, Barbara Bartocci (Editor), Stephen Read (Editor)

Paperback | 17 October 2024

At a Glance

Paperback


$45.05

or 4 interest-free payments of $11.26 with

 or 

Ships in 5 to 7 business days

Paradoxes, such as the Liar ('What I am saying is false'), fascinated medieval thinkers. What I said can't be true, for if it were, it would be false. So it must be false-but then it would be true after all. Attempts at a solution to this contradiction led such thinkers to develop their theories of meaning, reference and truth.


A popular response, until it was attacked at length by Thomas Bradwardine in the early 1320s, was to dismiss such self-reference as impossible: no term (here, 'false') could refer to (or in medieval terms, "supposit for") a whole, e.g., a proposition, of which it is part.


In light of Bradwardine's criticisms, Walter Segrave, writing around 1330, defended so-called restrictivism (restrictio) by claiming that such paradoxes exhibited a fallacy of accident. The classic example of this fallacy, the first of Aristotle's fallacies independent of language, is the Hidden Man puzzle: you know Coriscus, Coriscus is the one approaching, but you don't know the one approaching since, e.g., he is wearing a mask. But Aristotle's account is unclear and Segrave, building on ideas of Giles of Rome and Walter Burley, shows how the fallacy turns on an equivocation over the supposition of the middle term or one of the extremes in a syllogism. Thereby, Segrave is able to counter Bradwardine's arguments one by one and defend the restrictivist solution. In this volume, Segrave's text is edited from the three extant manuscripts, is translated into English, and is preceded by a substantial Introduction.

More in European History

The Mysterious Case of the Victorian Female Detective - Sara Lodge
Oliver Cromwell : Commander in Chief - Ronald Hutton

RRP $26.95

$22.99

15%
OFF
Holbein : Renaissance Master - Elizabeth Goldring

RRP $82.95

$60.75

27%
OFF
How Women Became Poets : A Gender History of Greek Literature - Emily Hauser
Armada : The Spanish Enterprise and England's Deliverance in 1588 - Colin Martin
The Glass Mountain : Escape and Discovery in Wartime Italy - Malcolm Gaskill
A Short History of Ancient Rome - Pascal Hughes

RRP $49.99

$47.75

Letters from a Stoic : The Ancient Classic - Seneca

RRP $24.95

$21.75

13%
OFF
The Catalpa Rescue - Peter FitzSimons

RRP $36.99

$29.75

20%
OFF
The Voynich Manuscript - Raymond Clemens

RRP $82.95

$60.75

27%
OFF
Abandoned Women : Scottish Convicts Exiled Beyond the Seas - Lucy Frost
The First King of England : Æthelstan and the Birth of a Kingdom - David Woodman
Jane Austen at Home : A Biography - Lucy Worsley

RRP $26.99

$22.99

15%
OFF
Churchill : Walking with Destiny - Andrew Roberts

RRP $35.00

$28.75

18%
OFF