The Lives and Legacies of a Carceral Island

"Curthoys, Konishi and Ludewig have succeeded in shedding light onto a little know period of Australia's aboriginal past through this manuscript on Rottnest's dark history. The Lives is a reading of the silences of Australia's island histories. It brings accountability, dignity and visibility to the repressed stories of Rottnest Island's penitentiary past. The authors have successfully created a gallery of buried lives. They read like snapshots of people one might even imagine having met: the brave little 14 year old English girl, Jane Green; the jovial Aboriginal prisoner Jumbo, the indefatigable Nurse Fay. The book tenderly reconstructs fragments of history's forgotten proleteriat through old fashioned archival work and historical research. The prose is lively, the stories are succinct. The result is a rare and poignant collection of indigenous, European and colonial island dweller portrayals of Australia's ostracized citizens, shaping the peripheries of modern Australia."

May Joseph, Pratt Institute, New York, USA

"While the authors wisely eschew any totalising narrative for the set of biographies they have presented, they do note that thissmall-scale history - the story of Wadjemup - is connected to a broader phenomenon of unfree labour which proliferated withthe Indian Ocean from the nineteenth century, in part because of the remoteness of this ocean itself from European populationcentres. As Curthoys, Konishi, and Ludewig set out compellingly in their opening discussion, the island's separateness aff ords inot only physical but also psychological distance from and for those who control it from the mainland."

Georgina Arnott, Australian Book Review, July 2023, no. 455

"In this exceptional co-authored book, Ann Curthoys, Shino Konishi and Alexandra Ludewig tell a compelling new history of Wadjemup/Rottnest. They reframe the island, 19 kilometres off the Western Australian (WA) coast, as part of a connected Indian Ocean and narrate its history through the lives of those who 'sojourned' there (1). The book presents the island's layered history: as a 'place where the spirits are taken', to Noongar people (4); as a landing site for early European expeditions; as a prison island for 3,700 Aboriginal people; as a site of internment for more than 1,100 German and Austro-Hungarian civilians in World War I; as a military base in World War II; and as a holiday resort in the twentieth century."

Katherine Roscoe, Australian Historical Studies, Book Review, August 2023, DOI: 10.1080/1031461X.2023.2233137