The Division of Wrongs : A Historical Comparative Study - Eric Descheemaeker

The Division of Wrongs

A Historical Comparative Study

By: Eric Descheemaeker

Hardcover | 24 April 2009

At a Glance

Hardcover


RRP $318.00

$187.50

41%OFF

or 4 interest-free payments of $46.88 with

 or 

Aims to ship in 5 to 10 business days

The common law, despite procedural divisions, has only ever had one class of civil wrongs. The civilians, by contrast, have typically split their law of wrongs in two, one group being called "delicts" and the other "quasi-delicts." Yet this division, which originated in Roman law, remains mysterious: it is clear neither where the line was drawn nor why a separation was made along this line.
This book does two things. In the first two parts, it investigates the origins of the division and its development in a modern civilian jurisdiction, France. What is argued for is that the Roman dichotomy was originally one between fault (culpa)-based and situational liability, which was prompted by a historical contraction of the Roman concept of a wrong (delictum). French law, building on medieval interpretations of the division, redrew the line one level higher, between deliberate and negligent wrongdoing. By doing so, it involved itself in severe taxonomical difficulties, which the book explores.
The third part of the work concerns itself with the significance of the civilian division of wrongs according to degrees of blameworthiness (dolus, culpa, casus) for the common law. A provocative thesis is developed, in effect, that there is a strong case for the adoption of a similar trichotomy as the first-level division of the English law of civil wrongs. From its formulary age, English law has inherited an unstable taxonomy where wrongs intersect. The existence of these mismatched categories continues to cause significant difficulties, which a realignment of causes of action along the above lines would rectify.
Industry Reviews
Dr Descheemaeker's book is genuinely to be welcomed as a fine piece of historical research and analysis on the doctrine devoted to legal classification. * Geoffrey Samuel, Cambridge Law Journal *
...this book is to be recommended...After two introductory chapters, the work is in three parts...in addition to advancing the overall thesis, each part contains valuable arguments with respect to the specific area considered. For a book which is both intricate and Polyglot, it is written in an accessible style * James Lee, University of Birmingham, Legal Studies, Vol 30.2 *
The current focus of tort scholarship - contemporary comparative analysis - cannot be undertaken properly without an idea of why legal systems structure their tort laws in the way they do. Descheemaeker's book is an invaluable contribution in that respect...The Division of Wrongs is a most impressive contribution to the field of delict. It displays a maturity of analysis and degree of comfort with seminal source material normally found in the work of n established author, and thus all the more remarkable in the first monograph of an academic at the start of his career. This book should certainly find a place in the library of anyone with a serious historical interest in the European law of wrongs. * Martin Hogg, Edinburgh Law Review Vol 14, 2010 *
The Division of Wrongs is an inventive and serious addition to the literature...Dr Descheemaeker...demonstrates the value of comparative and historical scholarship for private law jurisprudence. * James Lee, Legal Studies Vol. 30 N0.2, 2010 *

More in Torts

Australian Principles of Tort Law : 5th edition - Anita Stuhmcke

RRP $125.00

$104.95

16%
OFF
Connecting with Tort Law : 2nd edition - Julia Davis

RRP $136.95

$113.75

17%
OFF
The Law of Torts in Australia : 5th edition - Kit Barker

RRP $152.95

$125.75

18%
OFF
Australian Torts Law : 4th edition - Amanda Stickley

RRP $131.00

$106.35

19%
OFF
Fleming's The Law of Torts : 11th Edition - Carolyn Sappideen

RRP $245.00

$202.75

17%
OFF
Tort Law Principles : 2nd Edition - Bernadette Richards

RRP $172.00

$146.50

15%
OFF
Cases on Torts : 7th Edition - Barbara McDonald

RRP $130.00

$108.90

16%
OFF
Torts : 1st Edition - Principles, Skills & Application - Andrew Clarke
Private Law and the State - Andrew Robertson

RRP $220.00

$156.50

29%
OFF
Understanding Private Law : Essays in Honour of Stephen A Smith - Evan Fox-Decent
Life and Death in Private Law : Hart Studies in Private Law - Kate Falconer
Justice in Private Law : Hart Studies in Private Law - Peter Jaffey
Victorian Statutory Compensation Schemes : 1st Edition - Jason Taliadoros
Fleming's The Law of Torts : 10th Edition - Carolyn Sappideen

RRP $245.00

$202.75

17%
OFF
Preserving Appellate Complaints in Federal Courts - Reagan W. Simpson

RRP $270.00

$167.25

38%
OFF