In this original study, Jamie Mayerfeld undertakes a careful inquiry into the meaning and moral significance of suffering. Understanding suffering in hedonistic terms as an affliction of feeling, he addresses difficulties associated with its identification and measurement. He then turns to an examination of the duty to relieve suffering: its content, its weight relative to other moral considerations, and the role it should play in our lives.
Among the claims defended in the book are that suffering needs to be distinguished from both physical pain and the frustration of desire, that interpersonal comparisons of the intensity of happiness and suffering are possible, that several psychological processes hinder our awareness of other people's suffering, and that the prevention of suffering should often be pursued indirectly. Mayerfeld concludes his discussion by arguing that the reduction of suffering is morally more important than the promotion of happiness, and that most of us greatly underestimate the force of the duty to prevent suffering.
As the first systematic book-length inquiry into the moral significance of suffering, Suffering and Moral Responsibility makes an important contribution to moral philosophy and political theory, and will interest specialists in each of these areas.
Industry Reviews
"A wise and sensitive book...Mayerfeld has done a great service by drawing our attention to suffering. His arguments are careful and thoughtful, and this book should become the standard work on the topic." --Joan C. Tronto, American Political Science Review
"...provocative and insightful....This book would work well in a graduate ethics course."--Choice
"This book combines exacting, nuanced argumentation with a practical purpose that sets it apart from much work in philosophical ethics. At its best, it sharply focuses our attention on the experiences of both fictional and nonfictional individuals, variously placed along a hedonistic continuum, to illustrate the moral meaning of happiness and suffering."--Review of Metaphysics
"A wise and sensitive book...Mayerfeld has done a great service by drawing our attention to suffering. His arguments are careful and thoughtful, and this book should become the standard work on the topic." --Joan C. Tronto, American Political Science Review
"...provocative and insightful....This book would work well in a graduate ethics course."--Choice
"This book combines exacting, nuanced argumentation with a practical purpose that sets it apart from much work in philosophical ethics. At its best, it sharply focuses our attention on the experiences of both fictional and nonfictional individuals, variously placed along a hedonistic continuum, to illustrate the moral meaning of happiness and suffering."--Review of Metaphysics