+612 9045 4394
Socrates, Pleasure, and Value - George Rudebusch

Socrates, Pleasure, and Value

Hardcover Published: 1st May 1999
ISBN: 9780195128550
Number Of Pages: 188

Share This Book:


RRP $219.95
or 4 easy payments of $33.63 with Learn more
Ships in 10 to 15 business days

Other Available Editions (Hide)

  • Paperback View Product Published: 1st December 2002
    Ships in 10 to 15 business days

In the past quarter century, enormous philosophical attention has been paid to Plato's "Socratic" dialogues, as interpreters have sought to identify which dialogues are truly Socratic and interpret and defend the moral theories they find in those works. In spite of this intellectual energy, no consensus has emerged on the question of whether Socrates was a hedonist--whether he believed pleasure to be the good. In this study, George Rudebusch addresses this question and the textual puzzle from which it has arisen.
In the Protagoras, Plato has Socrates appeal to hedonism in order to assert his characteristic identification of virtue and knowledge. While in the Gorgias, Socrates attributes hedonism to his opponent and argues against it in defense of his own view that doing injustice is worse than suffering it. From the Apology and Crito, it is clear that Socrates believes virtue to be the supreme good. Taken together, scholars have found these texts to be incoherent and seek to account for them either in terms of the development of Plato's thinking or by denying that one or more of these texts was meant to reflect Socrates' own ethical theory.
Rudebusch argues instead that these texts do indeed fit together into a coherent moral theory as he attempts to locate Socrates' position on hedonism. He distinguishes Socrates' own hedonism from that which Socrates attacks elsewhere. Rudebusch also maintains that Socrates identifies pleasant activity with virtuous activity, describing Socrates' hedonism as one of activity, not sensation. This analysis allows for Socrates to find both virtue and pleasure to be the good, thus solving the textual puzzle and showing the power of Socratic argument in leading human beings toward the good.
Tackling some of the most fundamental debates over Socratic ethics in Plato's earlier dialogues, Socrates, Pleasure, and Value will generate renewed discussion among specialists and provide excellent reading for courses in ancient philosophy as well as ethical theory.

Industry Reviews

"I have encountered very few books that so refresh one's experience of reading Plato"--The Review of Metaphysics "I have encountered very few books that so refresh one's experience of reading Plato"--The Review of Metaphysics "In this excellent book, Rudebusch pursues this question to the heart of Socrates' ethics and concludes that Socrates is indeed a hedonist of an unusual kind....Every page of this extraordinary book offers spare but subtle argument without embellishment or distraction--a model of philosophical writing. Certainly the best book on Socratic ethics. Strongly recommended for college and university libraries."--Choice

ONE: Introduction TWO: Plato's Aporetic Style THREE: Ethical Protagoreanism FOUR: Callicles' Hedonism FIVE: Callicles Refuted SIX: Death Is One of Two Things SEVEN: The Intrinsic Value of Sense Pleasure and Pain EIGHT: The Righteous Are Happy NINE: Does Socrates Conistently Hold the Sufficiency Thesis? TEN: How Socrates Can Make Both Pleasure and Virtue the Chief Good Notes Bibliography Index of Passages General Index

ISBN: 9780195128550
ISBN-10: 0195128559
Audience: Professional
Format: Hardcover
Language: English
Number Of Pages: 188
Published: 1st May 1999
Publisher: Oxford University Press Inc
Country of Publication: US
Dimensions (cm): 24.13 x 15.88  x 1.91
Weight (kg): 0.48