+612 9045 4394
Rebellious Nuns : The Troubled History of a Mexican Convent, 1752-1863 - Margaret Chowning

Rebellious Nuns

The Troubled History of a Mexican Convent, 1752-1863

Hardcover Published: 1st December 2005
ISBN: 9780195182217
Number Of Pages: 296

Share This Book:


RRP $70.95
Ships in 10 to 15 business days

Earn 107 Qantas Points
on this Book

Nuns are hardly associated in the popular mind with rebellion and turmoil. In fact, convents have often been the scenes of conflict, but what went on behind the walls of convents was meant by the church to be mysterious. Great care was taken to prevent the "scandal" of factionalism in the nunneries from becoming widely known. This has made it very difficult to reconstruct the battles fought, the issues debated, and the relationships tested in such convents. Margaret Chowning has discovered a treasure-trove of documents that allow an intimate look at two crises that wracked the convent of La PurA-sima ConcepciA3n in San Miguel el Grande, New Spain (Mexico). At the heart of both rebellions were attempts by some nuns to impose a regimen of strict observance of their vows on the others, and the resistance mounted by those who had a different view of the convent and their own role in it. Would the community adopt as austere a lifestyle as they could endure, doing manual labor, suffering hunger and physical discomfort, deprived of the society of family and friends? Or would these women be allowed to lead comfortable and private lives when not at prayer? Accusations and counteraccusations flew. First one side and then the other seemed to have the upper hand. For a time, a mysterious and dramatic illness broke out among the rebellious nuns, capturing the limelight. Were they faking? Were they unconsciously influenced by their ringleader, the charismatic and manipulative young women who first experienced the "mal"? Rebellious Nuns covers the history of the convent from its founding in 1752 to the forced eviction of the nuns in 1863. While the period of rebellion is at the center of the narrative, Chowning also gives an account of the factors that led up to the crises and the rebellion's continuing repercussions on the convent in the decades to follow. Drawing on an abundance of sources, including numerous letters written by the bishop and local vicar as well as nuns of both factions, Chowning is able to give us not just the voices but the personalities of the nuns and other actors. In this way she makes it possible for us to empathize with all of them and to appreciate the complicated dynamics of having committed your life not only to God but to your community.

Industry Reviews

"Historians of colonial and modern Mexico, as well as students, will delight at a book rich in descriptive detail. The care with which Chowning treats her subject and the complex and nuanced assessment of this convent's life offer a treatsure of issues and topics for futher discussion and debate."--Martin Nesvig, The Historian "This book is a great resource for undergraduate students learning about historical research as well as for advanced scholars. Chowning brings the reader along in her interpretive process, explaining how sources such as letters, testimonies, and reports of nuns, bishops, and vicars were produced and paying attention to different perspectives and multiple possible interpretations of events. The result is a narrative of historical research that operates alongside the narrative about La Purísma. These arcs unite to present a fascinating picture of a group of women whose fortunes were intertwined with that of San Miguel and its region, and whose story illuminates the history of late colonial and early national Mexico for readers today."--Joan Bristoo, Journal of Social History "This is a beautiful little piece of research. Chowning has done an excellent job." --Church Times "This work offers a rare insight into the lives of cloistered nuns in late eighteenth century Mexico. Using conflict within the convent of La Purísima Concepción in San Miguel el Grande Chowning reveals the complex fabric of human relationships pulsating behind its walls. A debate on observance, carefully documented in hundreds of letters and private ecclesiastical sources, introduces the modern reader to the spectrum of interests, passions and machinations that plagued La Purísima for several years. An engaging narrative style, a judicious economic analysis and attention to detail recommends this study to historians of late colonial provincial society as well as historians of women and the church."--Asunción Lavrin, author of Women, Feminism, and Social Change in Argentina, Chile, and Uruguay, 1890-1940 "This superb book combines sophisticated scholarship with an entertaining story. Tracing the turbulent history of a Mexican convent from its foundation until the exclaustration of its nuns during the Reforma, Rebellious Nuns captures the texture of daily life inside the convent and the personalities of the strong-willed women who inhabited it. Chowning skillfully places her case study in the broader historical context to illuminate significant changes in women's roles, Catholic piety, and Church-State relations over a difficult century. This highly readable work will appeal to a wide audience of scholars as well as students in Latin American Studies and Women's Studies classes."--Silvia Marina Arrom, author of The Women of Mexico City, 1790-1857 "In this beautifully written book, a talented historian brings to life a memorable cast of characters: an Adam Smith-loving archbishop, a reform-minded abbess and her resistant charges, a provincial city in the throes of change. Her well-wrought narrative of a convent rebellion grounds sophisticated insights into key political, economic, and gender relations of the century she tackles. This extraordinary episode and its subsequent reverberations has found its rightful historian."--Pamela Voekel, author of Alone Before God: The Religious Origins of Modernity in Mexico "Chowning's work is a fine regional study of a broader phenomenon, convent rebellion, which illuminates larger trends. It will be required reading for those interested in women's convents, the economic history of the late colony and early nation, and the processes by which so-called Enlightenment thought penetrated even remote reaches of Mexican society." --American Historical Review "One of the most revealing glimpses inside a Mexican convent yet written. Just as impressively, the book situates the story of La Purisima within broad religious, political, and economic transformations, without blunting the nuance and historical idiosyncrasies of the convent and the nuns themselves." --Colonial Latin American Historical Review

An ill-fated convent for a pious townp. 21
The first crisis in the convent (1756-1762) : reforming abbesses and rebellious nunsp. 61
"Seminary of discord" : La Purisima under Phelipa de San Antonio, 1769-1772p. 101
"To live happily and in peace within ... their enclosure" : changing relationships among bishops, abbesses, and nuns, 1772-1792p. 151
Phelipa's vision triumphant : the abolition of the Vida Comunp. 183
La Purisima after independence : toward extinctionp. 219
Epilogue : the convent of La Purisima concepcion in post-reform Mexicop. 263
Bishops and abbesses, 1756-1863p. 271
Table of Contents provided by Blackwell. All Rights Reserved.

ISBN: 9780195182217
ISBN-10: 0195182219
Audience: Professional
Format: Hardcover
Language: English
Number Of Pages: 296
Published: 1st December 2005
Country of Publication: US
Dimensions (cm): 24.28 x 16.41  x 2.31
Weight (kg): 0.58

Earn 107 Qantas Points
on this Book