Daniel Russell examines Plato's subtle and insightful analysis of pleasure and explores its intimate connections with his discussions of value and human psychology. Russell offers a fresh perspective on how good things bear on happiness in Plato's ethics, and shows that, for Plato, pleasure cannot determine happiness because pleasure lacks a direction of its own. Plato presents wisdom as a skill of living that determines happiness by directing one's life as a whole, bringing about goodness in all areas of one's life, as a skill brings about order in its materials. The "materials" of the skill of living are, in the first instance, not things like money or health, but one's attitudes, emotions, and desires where things like money and health are concerned. Plato recognizes that these "materials" of the psyche are inchoate, ethically speaking, and in need of direction from wisdom. Among them is pleasure, which Plato treats not as a sensation but as an attitude with which one ascribes value to its object.
However, Plato also views pleasure, once shaped and directed by wisdom, as a crucial part of a virtuous character as a whole. Consequently, Plato rejects all forms of hedonism, which allows happiness to be determined by a part of the psyche that does not direct one's life but is among the materials to be directed. At the same time, Plato is also able to hold both that virtue is sufficient for happiness, and that pleasure is necessary for happiness, not as an addition to one's virtue, but as a constituent of one's whole virtuous character itself. Plato therefore offers an illuminating role for pleasure in ethics and psychology, one to which we may be unaccustomed: pleasure emerges not as a sensation or even a mode of activity, but as an attitude - one of the ways in which we construe our world--and as such, a central part of every character.
`Review from previous edition ... [Daniel Russell] finds considerably more coherence and philosophical interest than others have before him ... Anyone working in the field of ancient philosophy will want to own this book... It is not just that Russell develops his own views well, but he also has the gift of expressing others' or other possible views rigorously and fairly. This is a book to which I will return again and again; like all good academic books,
it forces the reader to refine his own views.'
Robin Waterfield, Bryn Mawr Classical Review
Introduction: Pleasure and the good life
1: Goodnes and the good life: the Euthydemus
2: Pleasure, virtue, and happiness in the Gorgias
3: Pleasure as a conditional good in the Phaedo
4: Pleasure and moral psychology in Republic IV and IX
5: The Philebus I: virtue, value, and 'likeness to God'
6: The Philebus II: pleasure transformed
7: Pleasure, value, and moral psychology in the Republic, Laws, and Timaeus
Epilogue: Pleasure and happiness in Plato's Protagoras