Do you own your body? Advances in science and the development of genetic databases have added an aura of modern controversy to this long-standing and, as yet, unresolved problem. In particular, English law governing separated human tissue (including body parts and cell-lines) is unsatisfactory. Despite the enactment of the Human Tissue Act 2004 UK, it remains uncertain what property rights living persons can claim over their separated human tissue. The development of clear legal principles is necessary so that individuals can have effective control over human tissue separated from their bodies whilst also enabling the efficient use of such materials in medical research.Part I of Law and the Human Body traces the evolution of English, Australian, United States and Canadian law in relation to human tissue separated from living persons and dead bodies. This includes a comprehensive examination of the Human Tissue Act 2004 UK as well as prominent judicial decisions, including Re Organ Retention Group Litigation [2005] QB 506, Colavito v New York Organ Donor Network 438 F 3d 214 (US CA 2nd Circuit 2006) and Washington University v Catalona 437 F Supp 2d 985 (USDC Ed Mo 2006). Analysis demonstrates that, although property rights and non-proprietary interests in separated human tissue are recognized in limited circumstances, no principled basis has been accepted either at common law or by statute for the recognition of these rights and interests. Part II of this book therefore develops and defends a principled basis in English law for the creation and legal recognition of property rights and non-proprietary interests in separated human tissue. Significantly, the analysis and principles presented in Law and the Human Body have application across common law and civil law jurisdictions worldwide.
Industry Reviews
Wherever one's sympathies or allegiances may lie along this spectrum, Hardcastle's book is a welcome and stimulating addition to the debate. It is the first text to present so detailed and comprehensive a black-letter legal analysis on point. Thought-provoking, unflinching, thoroughly researched in its descriptive content and well worth reading, it will appeal to academics across a range of disciplines, legal practitioners, policy-makers, lawmakers, biomedical researchers and biobanking professionals alike, both in the UK and internationally...One can also applaud the very welcome and timely addition of this significant, stimulating, refreshingly frank and often provocative new work to the growing canon of literature in this dynamic and important area. Susan M. C. Gibbons Medical Law Review 2008 ...a welcome addition to the literature of law and medicine. It summarises the existing state of the law comprehensively and provides informed insights into the way the law can legitimately employ property rights to govern an increasingly complicated area. The author is to be commended for a well-written, accessible book that is useful to both the legal and medical communities. Ben Kremer Bar News (The Journal of the NSW Bar Association) Summer 2008 Law and the Human Body has the potential to become, to law and the ownership of bodily materials, what John Seymour's 'Childbirth and the Law' is to law and pregnancy and Graeme Laurie's 'Genetic Privacy' is to genetics and the law: namely, a clear, comprehensive and modern treatment of a central legal and bioethical debate which no student or teacher of the law in that area can do without...an extremely useful volume which will be equally valuable to honours and postgraduate students and their teachers, and to researchers whose primary expertise is in another field but who find themselves in need of a reliable and readable guide to these issues...a vital edition to reading lists for classes in property law, bioethics, and possibly other classes besides, and a book of which all those involved in teaching or writing about this area of law should be aware. Mary Ford The Edinburgh Law Review Vol 12, 2008 The book provides a very informative analysis of the law in the countries examined. J.K.M. Gevers European Journal of Health Law Vol 15 (2008) This is a well written, largely black letter, book which engages in close and careful legal analysis and proffers a skilfully crafted argument. It is a readable and compelling thesis which deserves a wide audience within both the academic and practitioner global legal communities. Professor David Price Medical Law International Vol. 9 (2008) ...this book provides a powerful indictment of the current law on bodies. The first part of this book lays bare the lack of legal principle and analysis that underlies the law, even in the recent Human Tissue Act 2004. This is done in a scholarly and effective way. I have no doubt that Hardcastle's proposals for reform would produce a more intellectually satisfying state for the law to be in. Jonathan Herring Legal Studies Vol 28, No. 3 This book provides an excellent overview of the legal problems of proprietary and non-proprietary rights to the human body - not just under English law, but also under other common law jurisdictions. While the book may be interesting for readers from civil law jurisdictions, it is certainly of greater interest to scholars from common law countries. Renate Gertz SCRIPTed 6:2, 2009
