Aristotle thought of his logic and methodology as applications of the Socratic questioning method. In particular, logic was originally a study of answers necessitated by earlier answers. For Aristotle, thought-experiments were real experiments in the sense that by realizing forms in one's mind, one can read off their properties and interrelations. Treating forms as independent entities, knowable one by one, committed Aristotle to his mode of syllogistic explanation. He did not think of existence, predication and identity as separate senses of estin. Aristotle thus serves as an example of a thinker who did not rely on the distinction between the allegedly different Fregean senses, thereby shedding new light on our own conceptual presuppositions.
This collection comprises several striking interpretations that Jaakko Hintikka has put forward over the years, constituting a challenge not only to Aristotelian scholars and historians of ideas, but to everyone interested in logic, epistemology or metaphysics and in their history.
|Origin of the essays|
|On Aristotle's notion of existence|
|Semantical games, the alleged ambiguity of 'is', and Aristotelian categories|
|Aristotle's theory of thinking and its consequences for his methodology|
|On the role of modality in Aristotle's metaphysics|
|On the ingredients of an Aristotelian science|
|Aristotelian axiomatics and geometrical axiomatics|
|(with Ilpo Halonen) Aristotelian explanations|
|Aristotle's incontinent logician|
|On the development of Aristotle's ideas of scientific method and the structure of science|
|What was Aristotle doing in his early logic, anyway?: A reply to Woods and Hansen|
|Concepts of scientific method from Aristotle to Newton|
|The fallacy of fallacies|
|Socratic questioning, logic, and rhetoric|
|Table of Contents provided by Publisher. All Rights Reserved.|
Series: Jaakko Hintikka Selected Papers : Book 6
Number Of Pages: 238
Published: 1st June 2004
Publisher: Springer-Verlag New York Inc.
Country of Publication: US
Dimensions (cm): 23.5 x 15.5 x 1.91
Weight (kg): 1.19